Skip to content

Back to Our Blog

UU Analysis: NYHA Will Add Costs, Eliminate Jobs

Blog Categories

Kristine Bieniek

May 15, 2021

Upstate United, a BNP partner organization and non-partisan, pro-taxpayer, pro-economic growth, and pro-Upstate education advocacy coalition, recently analyzed the research on the potential economic impact of the New York Health Act (NYHA).

NYHA would move all state residents onto public plan

If enacted, the NYHA would impose a single-payer healthcare system for all New York residents.  The bill would force New Yorkers off their private health plans and instead put all state residents onto a public plan. Doing so would increase wait times, decrease access to quality care, repel top doctors from working in our state, and put many New Yorkers out of work.

Cuomo: A state-level single payer system is not feasible

Although any single-payer healthcare system has flaws, a state-level single payer system would be particularly problematic. The historic tax increases imposed by this bill would likely drive New York’s highest earners to move to neighboring states. Additionally, offering this level of care to all residents would draw high-need patients from around the country to move to New York. In other words, a state-level single-payer plan would attract those with the highest medical costs and drive out the taxpayers needed to finance the program. Governor Andrew Cuomo has taken the position that a state-level single payer system is not feasible, pointing to failed attempts in Vermont and California.

Upstate United’s analysis confirms the suspected problems with the NYHA, noting that the Act would cause:

  • An additional $253 billion in payroll taxes on employers and workers.
  • A loss of 161,000 jobs statewide, including 50,445 in the Upstate region.
  • A disproportionate number of job losses in Erie County.

UU’s full fact sheet is available here. 

Realities of Single Payer recently released a toolkit to help employers understand and communicate with lawmakers about the consequences of the New York Health Act. The toolkit is available here

Upstate United is a non-partisan, pro-taxpayer, pro-economic growth and pro-Upstate education and advocacy coalition made up of business and trade organizations from across Upstate New York.

Related Posts

Comptroller: “Duplication” in State Workforce Efforts

By jveronica@thepartnership.org | June 2, 2022

New York State Comptroller Tom DiNapoli recently released a report assessing the state Department of Labor’s workforce development efforts. The report found significant overlap, duplication, gaps, and fragmentation in state workforce development programs and services. The audit found that New York offers over 500 workforce development programs and services, administered

3.21.22 COVID Bulletin: State Reverses Course on HERO Act

By jveronica@thepartnership.org | March 21, 2022

Without fanfare, the New York State Department of Labor updated its website to announce the relaxation of some NY HERO Act provisions. Employers can now forego enforcing their workplace safety plans.

3.17.22 Advocacy Alert: Hochul Extends State of Emergency, Signs Sexual Harassment Bills

By jveronica@thepartnership.org | March 17, 2022

Governor Kathy Hochul has issued an Executive Order extending New York’s state of emergency declaration for COVID-19. The state of emergency was scheduled to expire today, but Hochul extended the declaration through April 15.

Empire Center: Single Payer “Sticker Shock”

By khilsdorf@thepartnership.org | March 17, 2022

A new report from the Empire Center for Public Policy details how expensive a single payer healthcare system would be in New York. The full report is available here.